Re: Peter Jackson and New Line Cinema to produce "The Hobbit"
I actually believe that the movies went well, and I am a huge LOTR fan, they just had to tweak it a bit to make it into a movie-length experience.
I cannot wait for this movie! The Hobbit is that kind of book that really doesn't need changing. But they HAVE to include these people and events:
-Tree top warg scene
-Goblin King
-Discovery of the ring, Gollum, and the riddle game (a must, for example, "Tell me what's in my pocket"), and the Misty Mountains in general.
-Elves scene + Elrond encounter
-Troll scene + Gandalf's trick to turn them into stone.
-The swords (biter, etc)
-Etc etc (Smog, Battle of Five Armies)
One of the things they have to include is the encounter with Beorn, and any fan of the series knows if Beorn isn't included, the movie will be ruined. He affects the story too much to be left out. (Also, perks like Gandalf's mention of Radagast should be included, since Gandalf isn't the only great wizard in Middle Earth)
With Pete and Fran producing the movie, I know if they choose the right parts of the book, it will be as good as the LOTR movies turned out.
I also believe that the first movie should end when the Gandalf bids farewell to the dwarves and Bilbo, and the group of heroes walk towards the dark woods. This is a great ending for me because it makes you guess what's next, and it is very convenient. I also believe the Mirkwood introduction was about at the middle-ish of the book, so what could go wrong :lol:
But what I am most excited about is Smaug, and how they will interpret him.