Sig Battle #7 Poll

[Evan]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

In the following post I do not intend to offend anyone:
The first one is just awful,read some tuts.Your focal point is not well placed,your lightning is off.
Fourth one is just text slapped on a background,the text does not blend with the background,this is nowhere near decent,it is not even a real sig.
Last one is half-decent at best,again just textblack stripe is not doing you any favours either,I dont think you did anything regarding the lightning.Third one is ok,nothing special,decent at best,text is rather bad,the lightning should be better,the focal point is ok.The only decent sig is the second one,the focal should be a litlle more to the right and the render should blend with the bg better,and you should never pu boarders,especially not black.

I did not mean to offend anyone,I just wanted to give some constructive critisicm.

that was harsh. this is a difficult theme in which you have to get really creative, it might not end up being zDominik's standards but they are still very good, and from what i gather you have high standards, so id be pleased to see you make one, then i will constructively critisize yours if youd like.

theres a report button right next to the rep one. think of what could happen if you continue to critisize this way.

 

[Dualist]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

think of what could happen if you continue to critisize this way.

The almighty Banhammer?

 

[Evan]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Precisely
:sly:

 

[Dualist]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Just 0out of curiosity, how long does this poll last?

Vote goes to Dualist.

:heart:

 

[Relinquished Reality]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

the poll lasts 4 one week.

 

[Dualist]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Thank you for that informative yet hard-to-read post.

 

[Azer249]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

that was harsh. this is a difficult theme in which you have to get really creative, it might not end up being zDominik's standards but they are still very good, and from what i gather you have high standards, so id be pleased to see you make one, then i will constructively critisize yours if youd like.

theres a report button right next to the rep one. think of what could happen if you continue to critisize this way.

Precisley it was hasrh i think everyone has done a great job and he just had overly high standerds

 

[droded]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

There are those who have created masterpieces in MS Paint,

 

[zDominik]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Ok,first off all you all have my apologies.As I said it was not my intention to offend anyone,so if I did I am sorry.

@Necromancer:

I have explained why I think what I said about those sig`s.

I did not mean to say you need PS to be a GFX designer,what I meant to say is:Getting PS might be useful because PS is certainly superior to other software.

I am from Croatia so my english is not perfect and I am sorry if I can not be understood on any deeper level.

Someone has asked to post some of my work:

So here it is:

This is my latest sig,it is nothing special,I did not do much with it,so feel free to criticise me:

The next one is my best sig by far:

Once again I am sorry for offending you all.

 

[Daemon300]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Azer for the win!

 

[Azer249]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Thanks deamon ^_^ i have a tear in my eye :'(

 

[Evan]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Someone has asked to post some of my work:

So here it is:

This is my latest sig,it is nothing special,I did not do much with it,so feel free to criticise me:

The next one is my best sig by far:

Once again I am sorry for offending you all.

what element of the periodic table are they?

 

[Zjuggernaut]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

I like that one.

That's just to cluttered.

 

[zDominik]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

I like that one.



That's just to cluttered.

thx for the feedback.

Evan,I did not do this for the poll so your comment is unnecesary and a bit dumb.

 

[Evan]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Why would I care of other siggys u can do? The argument was regarding how creative you could get with this theme and I'd critisized yours. You were critisizing siggys in this thread, everyone else critisized the siggys in this thread, this thread if for siggys relating to the periodic table, you can make anything else, but wat you made was unrelated and unecessary making you the dumb one for wasting your time.

 

[Dualist]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

I don't really care for either of the sigs you made. The first one seems quite plain, and the text doesn't blend at all; it just distracts the eye.

The second one would be much better if you had some kind of flow, as it looks like things are popping out at all directions. Maybe if you lower the fractal that's covering the clone trouper's arm.

 

[Gikoku]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

So here it is:

This is my latest sig,it is nothing special,I did not do much with it,so feel free to criticise me:

The next one is my best sig by far:

Once again I am sorry for offending you all.

You're right, they're not that good at all but they're not terrible either.

The second one is a big mess, good choice of colors, no flow, and the foreground effects have poor blending.

 

[Necromancer]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Someone has asked to post some of my work:

So here it is:

This is my latest sig,it is nothing special,I did not do much with it,so feel free to criticise me:

The next one is my best sig by far:

Once again I am sorry for offending you all.

I think the first one is a bit plain as well. As for the second one, it was a good choice of colors for the background, but it's a little difficult to figure out where the clone commando ends and where the background begins. The blue streaks don't look like the belong either.

 

[Evan]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

Necro, when is the outer space themed battle starting?

 

[Jasontated]

Re: Sig Battle #7 Poll

There all "pretty good" implying I know some thing you don't lawl

But... my votes for

Dualist