Re: Knothole Island - Cast Your Vote.
I actually liked it quite a bit. Sure, there could have been more content, but I think that it made a good add-on. I thought the quests were enjoyable and I like the new items. My only issue with it are the glitches, like the hair dye breakage I experienced (that didn't fix itself), and some people having their save games deleted by downloading it (which is simply ridiculous)