Re: Which is more annoying?
They both annoy me. But the Lucien people are worse. Jack people can argue that he does have some remote chance of being able to come back, and I guess he does. Lucien however, is dead. Case closed. Good or evil, pure or corrupted, by your hand or Reaver's, Lucien is dead. He was a mortal man with no powers of his own. He wasn't even of heroic blood. He was mortaly wounded, then fell down an extreamly deep hole that probably had spikes at the bottom. Hes gone for good. Next antagonist please.
Besides, bringing back the same bad guy for the sequel of a game is one of the biggest cliches in the buisness. And is not Lionheads style thankfully.
Then again, the Jack people are pretty bad too. "But in my game, I kept the mask!" Oh? Is that so? Well, good for you. But guess what? Lionhead doesnt care what you did in your game. This may be hard to swallow, but your insignificant and what you did in your game has no bearing on the story that Lionhead already has planned out. So STFU.