• Welcome to the Fable Community Forum!

    We're a group of fans who are passionate about the Fable series and video gaming.

    Register Log in

If you could do anything and get away with it...

But..... he could make a bolder he couldn't lift, then make himself able to lift it, so he's not unable to lift it anymore, but he couldn't lift it before, so he still couldn't lift it, but now he can.

:)

No but if that happens then he can indeed lift it.
 
But he couldn't before so he couldn't.

Hobbe you're not understanding one thing: He can make it so that he can lift it. Ergo, he can lift it. Adding an extra step to the process doesn't make both statements true.
 
Hobbe you're not understanding one thing: He can make it so that he can lift it. Ergo, he can lift it. Adding an extra step to the process doesn't make both statements true.

It does because he can't lift it at first, and he changes the properties of himself so TECHNICALLY he isn't himself anymore. So HE can lift it but his inferior past self cannot.
 
Yeah Hobbe, you fail at logic :P

Let's say I can lift 20 kilograms, and not 30. However, if I'm able to train hard enough to lift it in two weeks, I can lift it. All in all, the object that weighs 30 kilograms is ableto be lifted, even if I couldn't before.
 
Yeah Hobbe, you fail at logic :P

Let's say I can lift 20 kilograms, and not 30. However, if I'm able to train hard enough to lift it in two weeks, I can lift it. All in all, the object that weighs 30 kilograms is ableto be lifted, even if I couldn't before.

But... you couldn't. Then you made yourself able to. Whichever way you put the sentence:

"I couldn't lift it"

It still means... he could make a bolder he couldn't lift.

"God made a bolder he couldn't lift"

So... it works.

:troll:
 
But... you couldn't. Then you made yourself able to. Whichever way you put the sentence:

"I couldn't lift it"

It still means... he could make a bolder he couldn't lift.

"God made a bolder he couldn't lift"

So... it works.

:troll:

Listen, Hobbe, if God is omnipotent he should be able to do anything. Including creating a boulder that can not ever, not in eternity, by no one and I mean no one at all, be lifted. NEH-VAR. Just... unliftable. Even God shouldn't be able to, even if he tried to make himself able to. Then, if he after some magic spell is able to, even if he couldn't lift it before, the boulder does not meet the criteria of not being able to be lifted by anyone EVER, because it was lifted by someone, within eternity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arseface
god is what ever i believe him/her to be and i believe for that moment that hes a wuss
 
Listen, Hobbe, if God is omnipotent he should be able to do anything. Including creating a boulder that can not ever, not in eternity, by no one and I mean no one at all, be lifted. NEH-VAR. Just... unliftable. Even God shouldn't be able to, even if he tried to make himself able to. Then, if he after some magic spell is able to, even if he couldn't lift it before, the boulder does not meet the criteria of not being able to be lifted by anyone EVER, because it was lifted by someone, within eternity.

But God can do whatever the **** he wants, so if he really wanted to he could make a boulder that he just... couldn't lift. And that is the end of that.
 
Do not come between a pregnant woman and her boulder. NOW GIMME!
 
  • Like
Reactions: HobbeBrain